Legal Case Summary

Case Details
Case ID 2011b7e7-73e9-4b0e-8acf-ee3d7df560e3
Body View case body.
Case Number
Decision Date
Hearing Date
Decision The Lahore High Court held that the Provincial Government alone, under the provisions of Section 48 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, could withdraw from acquisition. The court emphasized that the Land Acquisition Rules, 1983, have been framed by the Provincial Government under Section 55 of the Land Acquisition Act, which stipulates that if no steps are taken under Section 5 within one year of the publication of the notification, the acquisition proceedings would automatically come to an end. Therefore, the withdrawal from acquisition as per Rule 7 would be deemed to have been done by the Provincial Government and not by order of its functionary. The court dismissed the appeals on the grounds that the rules are intra vires of the said Act and the Commissioner was not authorized to withdraw the notification, as the withdrawal had already occurred by operation of Rule 7.
Summary This case revolves around the interpretation of the Land Acquisition Act of 1894 and the accompanying rules that govern land acquisition processes in Punjab, Pakistan. The main issue was whether the Provincial Government could withdraw from the acquisition of land after a stipulated period had lapsed without any further action being taken. The Lahore High Court clarified that the rules established under the Land Acquisition Act allow for an automatic cessation of acquisition proceedings if no steps are taken within a year, reinforcing the authority of the Provincial Government in such matters. The ruling emphasized adherence to the legal framework and the importance of timely action in land acquisition processes, underscoring the role of the Provincial Government in making such determinations. This decision is significant for understanding the procedural aspects of land acquisition and the powers vested in governmental authorities, making it relevant for legal practitioners, landowners, and policymakers alike. Keywords such as 'Land Acquisition Act', 'Provincial Government', 'legal framework', and 'land rights' are pertinent in this context.
Court Lahore High Court
Entities Involved Ahbab Cooperative Housing Society Ltd., National Police Foundation Cooperative Housing Society Ltd., Board of Revenue, Government of Punjab, Lahore, CANTONMENT BOARD, BAHAWALPUR, Kh. Zubair Ahmad
Judges MUNIR A SHAIKH, AUSAF ALI KHAN
Lawyers M. Shamsher Iqbal Chughtai, Mr. M.M. Bhatti, M. Jaffar Hashmi, Nemo
Petitioners , Syed IQBAL MUSTAFA
Respondents CANTONMENT EXECUTIVE OFFICER, M.E. SECTION, CANTONMENT BOARD, BAHAWALPUR
Citations 1993 SLD 794, 1993 CLC 1489
Other Citations 1990 ALD 612 (2), PLD 1984 Lah. 191, 1990 MLD 1941
Laws Involved Land Acquisition Act (I of 1894), Land Acquisition Rules 1983
Sections 4, 5, 48, 55, R.7