Legal Case Summary

Case Details
Case ID 0c235f71-c427-4a52-9213-7f53d9276642
Body View case body.
Case Number Appeals Nos. RI-536 and 537 of 1988
Decision Date Jan 15, 1989
Hearing Date
Decision The Labour Appellate Tribunal dismissed the appeals filed by the appellants, who were employees of Pakistan Railways. The Tribunal found that the appellants could not claim overtime wages in addition to mileage allowance. The decision was based on the distinction between mileage allowance, which is provided in lieu of traveling expenses, and overtime wages, which are paid for work done beyond normal hours. The Tribunal emphasized that the appellants failed to provide evidence showing that they received overtime wages before the implementation of the mileage allowance cap in 1983. Consequently, the Tribunal upheld the lower court's decision, affirming that the appellants' claims were without merit.
Summary This case revolves around the distinction between mileage allowance and overtime wages for employees of Pakistan Railways. The appellants, who were attendants for air-conditioned coaches, argued that they were entitled to both payments. However, the Tribunal clarified that mileage allowance is intended to cover travel expenses and cannot be equated with overtime pay. The Tribunal referenced the Pakistan Railways Personnel Manual, which outlines the rules regarding allowances, including provisions for overtime under specific circumstances. The Tribunal ultimately dismissed the appeals, reinforcing the importance of adhering to established guidelines concerning employee compensation. This case highlights key issues in labor law, particularly in the context of public sector employment and the interpretation of allowances versus wages.
Court Labour Appellate Tribunal, Punjab
Entities Involved Pakistan Railways
Judges Sardar Muhammad Abdul Ghafoor Khan Lodhi
Lawyers Ch. Muhammad Akram, Agha Taj Muhammad
Petitioners Muhammad Ashraf, 20 others
Respondents Divisional Superintendent, Pakistan Railways, Rawalpindi
Citations 1989 SLD 1844, 1989 PLC 655
Other Citations Not available
Laws Involved Pakistan Railways Personnel Manual
Sections R.5(d), R.5(g)